In May 2019, the Court of Justice of the European Union issued a ruling that has since been cited by lawyers, HR professionals, and employment advisers: employers within the EU are required to introduce an objective, reliable, and accessible system for recording the daily working time of each employee. Not as a recommendation — as an obligation.

That ruling confirmed what was already implied in the EU Working Time Directive (Directive 2003/88/EC) but had rarely been enforced in practice. In the Netherlands, these obligations are anchored in the Arbeidstijdenwet (Working Time Act). This article explains what that law concretely requires of you as an employer.

PrikKlokPlus timesheet export — supports Working Time Act and EU directive registration duties

The EU Working Time Directive in brief

Directive 2003/88/EC of the European Parliament sets minimum standards for working hours across all EU member states. The core requirements:

  • Maximum 48 hours per week averaged over a reference period of 4 months (including overtime)
  • Minimum 11 consecutive hours of daily rest between two shifts
  • Minimum 24 hours of rest per week, preferably on Sunday
  • A break for shifts lasting more than 6 hours
  • Minimum 4 weeks of paid leave per year

The directive applies to employees. Self-employed individuals and independent contractors are not covered.

Checklist EU Working Time Directive for employers: maximum hours, rest periods, breaks and registration obligation

What the Dutch Working Time Act adds

The Netherlands implemented the directive through the Arbeidstijdenwet (ATW) and the Arbeidstijdenbesluit. On several points, Dutch standards go further than the European minimum:

  • Maximum 12 hours per shift
  • Maximum 60 hours per week (incidentally), averaged at 48 hours over 16 weeks
  • Under-18s are subject to additional protection rules
  • Specific sectors (transport, healthcare, offshore) have deviating norms under the Arbeidstijdenbesluit

Employers are required under the ATW to record the working hours of their employees and to be able to present that administration during an inspection by the Inspectie SZW. Retain hours records for at least 5 years; payroll and tax administration must be kept for 7 years.

The 2019 ruling: registration is not optional

In the case CCOO v Deutsche Bank (CJEU, 14 May 2019, C-55/18), the Court of Justice ruled that member states must require employers to introduce a system allowing the daily working time of each worker to be recorded objectively and reliably.

The Court reasoned that without such registration it is impossible to verify whether maximum working hours are being respected — and that the right to limited working time loses its practical effect if there is no administrative basis for enforcement.

For Dutch employers, the ruling itself changed little — the ATW already contained registration obligations — but it confirmed that informal or reconstructive timekeeping is insufficient.

What this means in practice for your business

Whether you run a small marketing agency or an SME with 50 employees: you are required to demonstrate when each employee worked. At minimum this requires:

  • Start and end time per shift per employee
  • Break times for shifts over 5.5 hours (ATW) or 6 hours (EU directive)
  • A system you retain and can produce on request

A WhatsApp group or a reconstruction from memory does not qualify. A paper form filled in weekly by the employee and signed by a manager is formally better — but error-prone and time-consuming.

Benefits of digital time tracking for compliance

A digital solution like PrikKlokPlus provides an audit trail that meets Inspectie SZW requirements:

  • Timestamp per entry — when an employee submitted hours is recorded
  • Approval history — the manager approves with date and time
  • Immutable after approval — corrections require manager action and leave a trail
  • Exportable — timesheets can be saved as PDF or CSV for your records

For small teams this provides the same compliance foundation as larger systems, without the complexity or cost.

Frequently asked questions

Does the registration requirement also apply to remote workers?

Yes. The Working Time Act makes no distinction between working at the office, from home, or on location. Employers are required to record the working hours of all employees regardless of where they work.

Can employees work more than 48 hours per week?

Employees can agree in writing to an opt-out from the 48-hour norm. That agreement may be withdrawn at any time. The maximum daily hours (12) and minimum daily rest (11 hours) continue to apply even with an opt-out.

What are the consequences of not keeping hours records?

The Inspectie SZW can impose fines during an inspection if hours records are missing or incomplete. Employees can also bring employment claims if they believe maximum working hours were exceeded and you cannot demonstrate otherwise. Consult an employment lawyer for the specific sanctions that may apply to your situation.

Is the EU working on a new working time directive?

Directive 2003/88/EC remains the current EU directive. The European Commission has consulted on modernisation — particularly around remote working and the right to disconnect — but no revised directive had been adopted as of 2026. Follow updates via EUR-Lex or the Dutch Ministry of Social Affairs and Employment.